Archived letter · Issue #15 · Sent November 22, 2026

This is the email exactly as it went out, unedited. Every price in it is as of the November 20, 2026 close, and none of it has been refreshed — a letter that gets quietly updated is not a record of anything.

← Every issue  ·  The workfile behind this issue  ·  Get the next one free

It costs 7.1 times earnings after a proposed cap on card interest rates knocked it down. The cap isn't law, and its loan losses are falling.
Travis Valuation
The Modern Value Investor, by Curtis Travis

The book is out

The Modern Value Investor

Thirteen ways to work out what a stock is worth, each run on a real company. My grandmother runs all through it, because the habits it rests on are hers: be patient, show your work, and know when you have enough.

Get the e-book → Paperback on Amazon.ca →

E-book CA$14.99 plus tax, with the audiobook included. Paperback CA$26.99.

Weekly Issue #15

Synchrony Financial (SYF) — $67.76 at Friday’s close

Synchrony is the lender behind the store cards of Amazon, Lowe’s, PayPal and Venmo, Sam’s Club and TJX, and behind CareCredit at the dentist and the vet. Last year it financed $182 billion of purchases across almost 71 million active accounts. It has made a profit every year since it left General Electric, and its earnings per share went from $2.71 in 2016 to $9.28 in 2025.

It also buys back a lot of its own stock. Buybacks have cut its diluted share count by 61% since 2015, and it has spent $2.85 billion on its own shares in the first nine months of this year. At Friday’s close of $67.76 it cost 7.1 times its last four quarters of earnings ($9.58 a share) and 1.42 times its book value. Investors marked it down this year over a proposed 10% limit on card interest rates, which would cut into the interest that makes up most of its revenue.

7.1×
Price to earnings, Nov 20 close
$2.71 → $9.28
Earnings per share, 2016 to 2025
−61%
Diluted shares since 2015

Earnings per share more than tripled in nine years while the share count was cut by more than half. The price is about seven times what it earns in a year.

Why it fell

Synchrony is 23% below its January 6 high of $88.47. The slide began on January 12. Three days earlier President Trump had posted that credit-card interest rates should be capped at 10% for a year, and Synchrony fell 8.4% on the next trading day, along with the other big card lenders. A cap would hit Synchrony harder than most banks, because nearly all of its revenue is interest on card balances. Its largest one-day fall, 9.6% on July 8, was shared by the whole group, and I can’t find a cause for it. Since January 1, Synchrony is down 19% and Capital One is down 26%.

The cap hasn’t happened

No cap has become law, a regulation or a voluntary program. A Senate bill for a 10% cap has sat in committee all year. That could change: after the November 3 midterms, both houses of the next Congress will be under Democratic control, and I can’t say how that vote will go. The shares are priced as if a cap were coming, and none has passed.

What the loans are doing

The number to watch at a card lender is how much of its loans it writes off. Synchrony’s fell to 4.79% in the third quarter, from 5.16% a year earlier, and to 4.4% in October. Its customers spent 8% more on its cards than a year earlier, with growth in all five of its business lines. On October 20 the company put its 2026 forecast at about $9.50 a share, the top of the range it gave in July. And in September 2025 it became the issuer of a new Walmart card program, through Walmart’s OnePay.

Synchrony Financial (SYF) — $67.76 at the Nov 20 close, down 19% this year

The check Reading Verdict
Price to earnings 7.1× ✓ Last four quarters ($9.58 a share); Ben Graham’s limit is 15
On the 2026 forecast 7.1× ✓ About $9.50 a share (October 20), the top of July’s range
Price to book 1.42× ✓ September 30 book of $47.64; P/E times P/B is about 10, well under Graham’s 22.5
Return on equity 21.0% ✓ Third quarter of 2026
Profitable years 10 of 10 ✓ 2016 to 2025; earnings per share up 3.4-fold
Diluted shares −61% ✓ Since 2015, from buybacks
Dividend 2.0% ✓ $1.36 a share a year; raised 13% this year and never cut since it began in 2016
Loan write-offs 4.79% ✓ Annualized, third quarter, down from 5.16% a year earlier; 4.4% in October
Five largest partners 52% ⚠ Of its loans: Amazon, Lowe’s, PayPal, Sam’s Club and TJX
A 10% rate cap Proposed ⚠ Would cut into its main source of revenue; not law

Price ratios at the Nov 20 close, earnings over the last four quarters, balance sheet at September 30. The Synchrony page on Travis Valuation → reads it 54% undervalued, an average of five formulas that includes two built on the company’s past growth. The three that assume no growth average $104.21, and the price is 35% below them. The page uses the audited 2025 annual report; the September 30 figures are shown here.

The catch

Four things. No Synchrony director or officer has bought shares on the open market in the past twelve months; they sold about $44 million, including about $15 million by the chief executive under a plan set up in October 2025. Its core capital ratio, the cushion regulators watch most closely, fell to 12.9% from 14.3% a year ago as the buybacks ran ahead. Five programs hold more than half of its loans, and losing one would hurt. And credit cards are where a recession shows up first.

What I can’t know

What Congress does. The 10% cap is a proposal. The new Congress sits in January.

Where losses go in a downturn. They are falling now. The company reports its write-offs every month, and its fourth-quarter report should come in late January.

Whether the big partners stay. Its agreements with its five largest run to between 2030 and 2035.

Skin in the game

I do not own Synchrony, and I will not buy any until after this letter has gone out. I do own Amazon and Walmart, two of its partners.

Warren Buffett wrote in his 2001 letter that “you only find out who is swimming naked when the tide goes out.” For a card lender the tide is a recession. In the last one, 2020, Synchrony still made a profit and kept paying its dividend.

Which account?

Synchrony pays $0.34 a share a quarter, $1.36 a year, about a 2.0% yield. The 15% US withholding comes to about 20 cents a share a year if your broker has a W-8BEN form on file for you. The withholding does not apply inside an RRSP. In a non-registered account you can claim it back as a foreign tax credit. In a TFSA it is lost. With a small dividend and most of the cash going to buybacks, the case is mostly about the price, and a gain is tax-free in a TFSA. General information, not tax advice.

Run the numbers yourself →

The workfile

Everything above is the short version. The workfile has the price path date by date, the rate-cap history, ten years of earnings and dividends, the write-off figures quarter by quarter and month by month, the buybacks and the funding, every valuation method on one page, and why Cognizant, MGIC and three others were set aside this week. It’s in this week’s workfile →

Your turn 👇

Which stock should we run through the checks next? Hit reply with a ticker.

Send me your pick →

Curtis Travis, B.Comm, AACI (retired), is the founder of Travis Valuation. He does not own Synchrony Financial, the subject of this issue. He owns shares of Amazon and Walmart, both Synchrony partners, and of VICI Properties, Lennar, Costco, TD, Scotiabank, Dick’s, Berkshire Hathaway and OMAB, all named in past issues. Prices, ratios and earnings are as of the Nov 20, 2026 close or the latest filing, from market data and Synchrony’s own SEC filings; the valuation figures are from the Synchrony page on Travis Valuation. The rate-cap history is as reported by the press. Prices move. Informational only — not a recommendation, and not tax advice. Do your own diligence.

travisvaluation.ca  ·  Instagram  ·  LinkedIn